Error: All In EV calculations are wrong?

Questions and discussion about PokerTracker 4 for Windows

Moderators: WhiteRider, kraada, Flag_Hippo, morny, Moderators

Error: All In EV calculations are wrong?

Postby _dave_ » Sat Dec 24, 2011 12:13 am

I imported a few hundred hu sngs, and when I finally figured out how to show equity adjusted line, I notice it is different no HEM and start to wonder why.

Side note: Need ability to "Overlay Net Adjusted" on the main graph in "Results". imo this is vital, ROI and ITM trending is completely useless in comparison. Maybe I'm missig a checkbox somewhere?


Anyway, on to the meat of the problem. Today I played 6 games, and the EV graphs are quite different. here are some pics. AFAIK, HEM1 is "correct".

compare_graphs.png
(111.33 KiB) Downloaded 2982 times


Sorry for the large pic, I ave a large monitor and wanted to show side by side.

As you can see, the adjusted EV line is different. in HEM it crosses over at game #4, in PT4 is does not quite touch. and the end of the graph is different, PT4 say's I'm up almost $10 of EV ($9.40), HEM is more conservative and only thinks I should have won a mere $7.40.

So I looked into things a bit further, and found this:

hand_detail.png
(25.46 KiB) Downloaded 2898 times


As you can see, I got AQo all in pre and ended up failing to suck out on a 99, for a lot of bb. Interestingly, the equities reported by HEM and PT4 are different! HEM claims 44.6%, PT4 is less confident in my AQ, giving it only 44.36%. maybe PT4 knows something all to obvious to me (it's a tiny bit rigged ldo!) - but those are not the proper odds. I checked in PokerStove, thus:

pokerstove_aq_vs_99_exact suits.png
(16.68 KiB) Downloaded 2894 times


44.615%. I also checked generic AQo vs 99, it makes little odds (I have a 0.001% extra equity having his 4 card flush draw to spades dominated)
_dave_
 
Posts: 1147
Joined: Sun Dec 09, 2007 6:19 pm

Re: Error: All In EV calculations are wrong?

Postby _dave_ » Sat Dec 24, 2011 12:19 am

NEW POST FOR LIMIT OF 3 ATTACHMENTS PER POST :(

So I checked PT4's equity calc, first time I've used it:

pt4_eq.png
(35.75 KiB) Downloaded 2960 times


wtf is going on here? yet another equity amount?!?!?!

Obv I know what is going on here, but why are using a 25 million trial monte carlo for a preflop exact matchup? and given it took near 10 seconds and still didn't get accurate, what on earth is going on for the imported HH? a tiny-sample monte-carlo? this has to be accurate, and done with a precomputed lookup table or an accurate exhaustive evaluator, imo.


Sidenote #2 - very annoying that the hand replayer, and it's child equity calculator are modal and stop interaction with the main PT4 window while open. is there a need for this?
_dave_
 
Posts: 1147
Joined: Sun Dec 09, 2007 6:19 pm

Re: Error: All In EV calculations are wrong?

Postby Yogi Rob » Sat Dec 24, 2011 1:08 am

_dave_,

Thanks for all the feedback. We have many improvements to this area planned.

If you use the equity calculator for AQo vs 99, or AsQc vs 99, or AQo vs 9h9s, you'll see immediate results.

For specific hand vs hand situations we're doing raw monte carlo (for now), but we have lots of optimizations on the drawing board. Precision inconsistencies you're seeing are due to sample size when monte carlo sims are required.

Very serious consideration will be given to all your other suggestions too. We will have many updates coming in the upcoming weeks. Please stay tuned - we're very glad to have you involved in the beta process.
Yogi Rob
Developer
 
Posts: 1078
Joined: Tue Jul 07, 2009 9:33 pm

Re: Error: All In EV calculations are wrong?

Postby _dave_ » Sat Dec 24, 2011 2:02 am

Yogi Rob wrote:_dave_,
If you use the equity calculator for AQo vs 99, or AsQc vs 99, or AQo vs 9h9s, you'll see immediate results.


Excellent - just checked this, AsQc vs 99 gives the correct result, 44.614%, delivered instantly :)

The most important thing is imo that this is wrong for producing the EV graphs, and wrong in a very large way. like, +$2 over 6x $7 games is like near an extra ~5% ROI, enough to make a loser think they're a marginal winner. It's still not clear what's going on during import since I couldn't find a way to make the built in EV calc come up with the same result. For now maybe just "condense" imported hands to their generic AQo vs 99 variant, to avoid errors in EV graph?
_dave_
 
Posts: 1147
Joined: Sun Dec 09, 2007 6:19 pm

Re: Error: All In EV calculations are wrong?

Postby Yogi Rob » Sat Dec 24, 2011 1:16 pm

_dave_ wrote:For now maybe just "condense" imported hands to their generic AQo vs 99 variant, to avoid errors in EV graph?


We do this in ICM analysis for the known hand when it's always one known hand vs a known range. Flush draw trouble emerges when it's specific hand vs specific hand. Results are very close in a lot of cases, but for example AQs vs KJs (61.7/38.2) and AsQs vs KsJs (64.1/35.9). We have something in mind for very quick and near perfect results for all cases.
Yogi Rob
Developer
 
Posts: 1078
Joined: Tue Jul 07, 2009 9:33 pm


Return to PokerTracker 4

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests